| Christine Ross of SG Hambros answered your investment queries and problems on the programme and in a live webchat.
Click here for Christine’s question and answer session from the programme.
Here is the full transcript of the live webchat.
Do you think that investing in residential property in Bulgaria is still viable or do you think that the dating free online service uk
amount of supply available will diminish any capital gains in the future?
J. Heath.
There has been considerable interest of late in investment in Bulgarian property. All markets eventually find their own level so in time it is likely to become more expensive - rewarding early investors.
There are many start up organisations offering investment opportunities and it is important to know where your money is going and how you are going to get it back again. There are many legitimate operators but if the offer sounds too good it probably is.
What is your opinion of Standard Life? Are the shares worth keeping shares when if and when they demutualise?
And what about the policy itself - mine is not linked to any mortgage - will it be a good time to cash it in?
Dave Stafford.
Standard Life is a respected mutual insurer. Whether you retain the shares will really depend on what part of your overall wealth they represent and if you have an appetite for the risk associated with holding single stocks - more risky because you have less opportunity to diversify.
Regarding your endowment policy, you generally lose out by cashing a policy in early and Standard Life policies have generally offered good returns. If it is near to maturity you might want to hold on. If not, you need to compare investment in this product (where the actual fund pays basic rate tax) with an ISA where returns are more tax efficient.
Don’t forget that the policy gives you life insurance cover - consider whether you still need this.
Can losses on stocks and shares investments be offset to reclaim tax paid on bank and building society savings interest in a tax year?
Peter Watts.
Unfortunately not. Capital gains tax is charged on stocks and shares where as income tax is levied on savings. A capital loss cannot be offset against income. However, capital losses can be carried forward indefinitely so when you make some profits on shares or unit trusts in the future these can be tax free.
How much risk is there really in investing in the higher risk categories of unit trusts, like for example global emerging markets funds? Unless you need to take out your money in a hurry, don’t they always pay out really well in the longer term?
Alison Saville.
Many organisations try to measure risk. The way I think about it is to compare the level of risk you are prepared to take for a given return. If you want a 15% return you could be looking at losing 30% or more of your capital. Funds have gone down as much as 70%. Could you live with that? If you are prepared to hold on for the very long term you could do well but often more modest and steady annual returns give a better pay off in the long run.
Will the lump sum from my pension plan attract any tax at all in particular capital gains?
Diane Rae.
No it will not. This is a concession under the pension scheme rules and many savers take advantage of this so that they can invest this efficiently to provide an income to supplement their pension. It is also referred to as your tax free lump sum.
I have decided today to invest 14,000 into a L&G Growth Portfolio Trust. I will use my next two years of ISA allowance, and my aim is for long term growth, e.g. 5-10 years. Given the drops in the FTSE and world markets this week, is this the best thing to do right now? Or would you advise taking a little less risk now?
Robert Clothier.
As you say, this is intended to be a long term investment. Therefore, over the next few years the short term ups and downs of the markets will even out. It is difficult to call the turn of the market but having considered where the market has been going in the last week it might be worth waiting a little before making your investment. You do seem to have considered your overall strategy so if you are happy with this a short term fluctuation should not lead you to change this. If you are really unsure, then perhaps this strategy was not exactly right for you in the first place.
I have a regular income and a variety of investments, ISAs, commercial property bonds etc, some of which I have held for seven or more years which are on average delivering me a return of 15% on paper. I also have a mortgage of 305,000 - a base-rate tracker mortgage with the Abbey which is less than 7%. Should I sell my investments to pay off my mortgage and then start investing again?
Jennifer Newns.
It is difficult to tell you to pay off a mortgage which is costing 7% when you are making 15% but investments returns of the sort you are achieving are generally not sustainable over the long term. Therefore I think you could consider banking some of your profit which you could use to reduce your mortgage. You will need to think about any tax that might be due when you sell your investments. Another reason for selling a bit at a time is that by utilising your annual capital gains tax (CGT) allowance each year you can make up to 8,800 (in tax year 2006/07) of tax-free profits.
I would like some advice on investments, this year my dad is turning 50 and I want to know what investment options there are out there. I want to buy him some form of investment as a birthday gift. I have 5,000 to start with.
Hema Thanky.
The many investment options would be too numerous to list. How about Premium Bonds? These are safe in that you don’t lose your capital but offer the chance of a big win. You can find details on the National Savings & Investments website.
You can give 3,000 to friends and relations with no tax becoming liable on the gift. Can my wife and I we give 3,000 worth of our house per year (drawn up as a legal commitment) to my two boys as a way of reducing their tax liability on our estate upon our death?
Chris Rainey.
The problem you will come up against is the gift with reservation (GWR) rule. If you give something away you cannot continue to benefit from it. If you continued to live in your house you would fall foul of this rule unless you paid a commercial rent to your sons in respect of the portion passed to them. There are all sorts of other reasons why you should not do this - relating to your continued security of tenure. It may be worth having a discussion with a solicitor about estate planning options. The first visit should be free. The last budget contained far reaching proposals relating to trusts, estate planning and inheritance tax so it would be worthwhile waiting to do this until the Finance Bill is passed (about early August) - after that time the picture will be clearer.
Are these companies who buy up your endowment taking a huge risk based on all the financial advice pointing to them being a bad investment or is there a way they maximise their profit that the individual cannot exploit? Do they know something we don’t? Why do they do it when there are far better investment opportunities available?
Colin, Liverpool.
In general, second hand policy traders match purchasers and sellers of endowment policies. They generally only trade with profits policies which will have embedded value. The traders know which companies policies are likely to be more attractive to investors. They find the investors who are prepared to continue to pay the premiums until maturity and take the profits at that time.
I’ve been thinking about buying several buy-to-let properties to use as a long term investment. What is the most tax efficient way of doing this? Is it possible to put them into a pension at all, and is there any benefit to having them as top online dating
or repayment from a tax perspective?
Sam Harnett.
It is not possible to hold residential property in a pension scheme. If you are able, it is tax efficient to take out a mortgage on a buy to let property as the mortgage interest can usually be deducted from the rental income as an expense. This in return reduces the amount of income tax you pay on the rental income. If the expenses associated with the buy to let (mortgage interest, wear and tear, management fees etc) equal the rental income then there should be no tax to pay.
Whether you choose an interest only or repayment mortgage will depend on whether you plan to keep the property in the long term. As the mortgage is repaid the amount of interest will reduce (if interest rates stay where they are). Therefore you could start to pay tax on the rental income. If you want to keep the properties in the long term you may need to opt for repayment unless you have any other way of paying off the loans.
What is your opinion of Exchange Traded Funds?
Sheila Mackay.
In general I like them. They can be cheaper than unit trust tracker funds and allow you to gain exposure to specific market sectors. They are easy to trade and to get in and out of. If you haven’t already, take a look at the Barclays iShares site.
Can you tell me where I can find a good local personal financial adviser?
Andrew Beavin.
In all honesty the best way to find an adviser is through dating meeting online service
. If you don’t know anyone who has a good adviser then I suggest you ‘interview’ maybe three different advisers. Many advisers have to be all rounders but you will find that they tend to specialise in one or two particular areas. Choose the specialty that most closely matches your needs - e.g. investment, pensions, tax planning.
Try IFA Promotion (www.unbiased.co.uk) who will give you names of advisers in your post code area. Also look at the Financial Services Authority site (www.fsa.org.uk). They have a list of fee only advisers.
I have put savings in ICICI bank quite recently, what is the web address you gave on the programme to check their rating?
Tim.
The two main ratings agencies are Standard & Poor’s (www.standardandpoors.com/ratings) and Moody’s (www.moodys.com). These issue credit rating for companies based on their levels of debt and financial stability. They are not directly intended for customers, but will give you an indication of the firm’s size and strength.
I have a unit-linked endowment policy which I was told would pay my mortgage off in 15 years, possibly with a large lump sum. My mortgage doesn’t depend on the policy. Do I still have a case to complain about mis-selling as it is a unit linked and not a ‘with profits’ policy?
Martin Wright.
You may have a complaint if you were told the policy would pay off your mortgage, regardless of whether you still need it for this purpose. The complaint does not depend on it being a unit linked or with profits policy as neither necessarily offer the guarantee - only a guaranteed maturity value will do that.
In the first instance you need to write to the compliance officer at the IFA. They will respond to you and will handle your complaint in line with prescribed guidelines. If the response you receive does not resolve the matter to your satisfaction then you can complain to the Financial Services Ombudsman. The IFA will tell you how to do this in their response to you.
Here are Christine’s answers from the programme…
I am a complete interest rate tart and while searching for best rates came across a bank called ICICI which I had not heard of - are they safe? Would like to put about 300,000 in their savings account. As usual the one I am with now (Northern Rock) will not let me open another account with bonus rates.
Jeremy, Norfolk.
If it sounds too good to be true it usually is. As a UK investor you are offered some protection if a financial institution fails, but you should not make investment decisions on the existence of a compensation scheme alone as it could take a considerable time to be paid out. You should look at the credit rating of any institution before investing. Credit ratings are provided by agencies such as Moodys and Standard and Poors. A deposit taker with AAA or AA will be the strongest, but a single A can still be considered. Once you get into the B’s you are taking on more risk and that is why higher interest rates are offered. Have a look at www.moneyfacts.co.uk, for the best rates, remembering that those offered for accounts operated by phone or over the internet are usually higher.
I changed my mortgage from an endowment to a normal repayment a couple of years ago, as it wasn’t going to pay off my mortgage at the end of its term. I have continued to pay the endowment payments and have around 2,500 in the pot. What should I do? Should I continue to make the payments for the full term and see what I get at the end or should I cash in or sell the endowment policy and invest it somewhere else?
Louise Davidson.
The problem with ceasing payments or surrendering an endowment policy is that you have paid most of the costs up front, so invariably lose out. This has to be balanced with the fact that there are now cheaper and more tax efficient methods of saving, such as ISAs. If your endowment has not been running for long I would consider selling it if you can. Otherwise you may just want to make it paid-up - that is make no further contributions and allow the present value to grow until maturity.
There seems to be a wide variation in the amount of dividends unit trusts pay out. For instance Fidelity Special Situations pays a dividend of only 0.35% yet it invests in stocks like BP which pay a much higher dividend. What happens to the dividends unit trusts receive from the companies they invest in - do investors receive this as income, capital gains, or do the funds pocket the money themselves?
Mark, Poole.
UK unit trusts are categorised according to their investment objectives, such as UK Growth, UK Income etc. and generally have to pay out 85% of all income received in the fund. Fidelity’s Special Situations is a growth fund that focuses on value stocks - that is shares that the manager believes are under valued. Whilst it may hold BP it could also hold shares that pay little or no income, so the total dividend paid out by the fund will reflect the average of all dividends received from the portfolio. The investment groups certainly do not keep the money themselves, but many trusts to use some of the income to pay the annual management fee.
An important point that you didn’t mention when you recently covered guaranteed equity bonds, is that profits are taxed as income, and not as capital gains. Therefore, for instance, on the National Savings bond, although you think that you are going to get 112% of the rise in the index, if you pay basic rate tax you get only 90% of the rise, and if you pay higher-rate tax you get only 67%. This, plus the lack of dividends, means that you are paying heavily for the guarantee of not losing your capital.
This is one way of looking at it, but then we also pay tax on other investments. Because of the way guaranteed investments are structured, they are often subject to income tax rather than capital gains tax. This means we miss out on using our annual CGT exemption - 8,800 for the current year. The important thing to remember is that there is no free lunch - the guarantee has to be paid for - and it is usual to use the dividend income to do this. So the real question is whether the guarantee is really needed. If someone can afford to invest for the long term and can weather the ups and downs of the market, then perhaps a guarantee is unnecessary.
I am in the process of remortgaging my house and taking out a buy-to-let mortgage. I am remortgaging and releasing an extra 30,000 to make a down payment on another house which I will live in. Do you have any suggestions as to the best place to invest the 30,000 while I search for a property which could take a few months. What about Premium Bonds?
If the money is required in the short term then a cash deposit is the best place. I do like Premium Bonds but you are gambling the interest you would receive on a deposit in the hope of a greater payout. If you can afford to do this and still keep up payments on your other loans then I think splitting your deposit is a good idea. Check out the best cash rates at www.moneyfacts.co.uk
In November 2000 I invested a sum of 10,000 in a Standard Life with profits bond. In March 2006 I asked for a valuation on my bond, which was given as 11,498 and carrying a Unit Price Adjustment (currently called an MVA by other companies) of 2,428. This is more than 25% of the original investment of 10,000.
Harry Barker.
Whether it’s an MVA or a UVA it amounts to the fact that a with profits investment is supposed to smooth out stock market returns. Each year a bonus is added to the value of your investment. The level of the bonus will depend on the market returns achieved by the fund. When markets fall, the value of your investment does not decrease, but you may receive no bonus that year, and even in subsequent years. Additionally, a penalty may be levied if you withdraw funds. Taking your example, you invested near to the top of the market in 2000. In 2001 and 2002 the market fell dating free online sex site
, and if you had been invested in, for example, a unit trust, the value of your investment would have fallen. The investments underlying the with profits fund appear not to have recovered their 2000 value and so if you want to withdraw your money, the company is saying you must take a reduction in value so that the money paid out to you truly reflects the value of your share of the fund.
A number of years ago, I invested 2,000 in what was then called ‘Carnegie Building Societies Investment Trusts’ and are now are know as ‘Blue Planet Financials Growth and Income Investment Trusts’. Along with my ten investment trusts shares come 40 warrants per trust. I do not know whether the price is worth exercising and I admit I do not quite understand warrants. Do I just ignore these warrants or am I sitting on a gold mine?
Those investing at the launch of a new investment trust are often given free warrants - perhaps, for example, one for every five investment trust shares purchased. These warrants usually give the investor the opportunity to buy further shares at a future date or dates, for a top online dating
price. The warrants will have a value if the share price has increased and the warrant price is lower. For example, the investor may be able to buy further shares at year three onwards, at 1 per share. If at that time the shares are worth 1.50 then the warrant has a value. If you look up the price of the investment trust shares in the newspaper you should see the price of the corresponding warrants listed there too.
I am approaching retirement and have a number of PEPs and ISAs which contain investment trusts that are largely share based, in fact mostly income growth trusts. The established opinion seems to suggest that I should have a major portion of my investments in fixed interest investments like corporate bonds. Having looked at the grouped investments for corporate bonds, they seem to me to have higher charges than my investment trusts and offer interest that isn’t much more than I could get from a high interest bank or building society account. Why should I invest in them, am I missing something?
Mark, Poole.
The idea behind a move to bonds or other fixed interest securities is to stabilise the value of your capital as the time when you will need to start relying on an income draws near. Many investors may need to withdraw their capital for a specific purpose and others will need to invest in assets that produce a higher level of income than their equity based portfolios. Therefore there may be a need to protect the capital, and to shift the focus from capital growth to income production. If the level of income you receive from your existing investments is sufficient, or indeed if you will not need to rely on these investments to supplement any other retirement income (such as a pension) then there is no absolute need to alter your investment strategy. The real test is to consider how a stock market fall might affect you, and would you be able to continue to hold on to your investments while you waited for the market to recover.
My wife and I each have a Maxi ISA with Abbey, the initial investment having been the maximum 7,000 each in March 2004.
So far the return has been very good (50% over two years), however appreciating that this is probably due to the steady recovery in the FTSE during that time, would we be wise to cash in the ISAs now that the market is showing signs of a decline or should we just sit tight and hope that the fund manager can weather the storm?
Ian Wilson.
A very relevant question. You certainly invested at the right time and as you will have seen, the market has taken a breather from its upward climb. If you were just starting out on this I investment I would have told you that you needed to take a long term view and that means at least five years, preferably longer. I do not believe the market is going all the way down again, but equally do not think you should expect returns to continue as they have. If you are willing to accept some volatility in the short term in exchange for long term growth then you should not be disappointed. A manager cannot protect an equity fund completely from the downside so if you want to consolidate your profit it may be a good idea to ask Abbey if they can offer a free switch into a lower risk fund.
My husband and I have two PEPs each. This year’s statements show that they are now valued at 36,000. Since PEPs stopped we have invested money in ISAs. We now are unsure what to do with
the PEPs. Should we take the cash and reinvest it?
Dorothy Hamilton.
Although PEPs were replaced by ISAs some time ago, both type of investment still offer tax free returns - that is you do not pay tax when you take money out of your investments. However, both PEPs and ISAs can no longer claim back the tax that is deducted at source from dividends. PEPs can be invested in a wide selection of shares and fixed interest securities, but not in cash. It may be that you do not need to make any changes to your investments, but it does sound as if it has been some time since you have reviewed your overall strategy during which time your circumstances may have changed. To start with you should consider when you might retire and if you will need to start drawing an income from your investments. I think you might find it helpful to have an initial (free) meeting with an Independent Financial Adviser to discuss your overall objectives and to see if you could benefit from taking professional advice.
We took out a guaranteed equity bonds such a bond in my wife’s name three years ago and although it was a five year term it will mature this year due to the FTSE having increased by more than 30%. A downside to this type of investment is that all the gains are lumped into a single return and hence one tax year. As a non-tax payer my wife has registered an R85 in order to have the income paid without tax deducted. However this together with other income may move her above the tax threshold for this tax year. My question is can the income be divided across the three years of the bond for income tax purposes, effectively using her unused allowances from previous years so that she is not liable for tax this year?
Graham Marshall, Congleton.
Unfortunately not. When the bond matures this will constitute a surrender in this tax year. However, this may be an onshore insurance bond, so you may find that, as long as the profits all piling into one year does not make your wife a higher rate taxpayer, there will be no tax to pay. This is because basic rate income tax will have been deducted within the bond. If the investment is not an insurance bond then it is likely that the full amount of profit will be subject to income tax in the year of encashment.
The opinions expressed are Christine’s, not the programme’s. The answers are not intended to be definitive and should be used for guidance only. Always seek professional advice for your own particular situation.
|